Hang on, it gets 'fun' in this one. You know the timeline, but I sent the email below back to Matt tonight.
11/13, Friday - Julia texted to see if Jake coming Monday afternoon works for me, and I assented. At least they are paying attention to my request that work only happens when I'm here.
11/16, Monday - Jake texted me in the afternoon to see if he could show up early. (At least they've paid attention to my request that no one show up without me knowing.) I said yes, and arrived home to find him working less than an hour later. He completed the work to be done shortly after sunset.
Jake was a good guy. He saw the shoddy job and couldn't believe it, himself. Here is what the seam between the porch and the house looks like now.
11/17, Tuesday - I received an email from Matt asking if I wanted a walk-through or if I was happy with things and would sign the completion form. He also noted that I wanted to talk about a discount and asked what sort of discount I was looking for? Okay, I'll have to spell it out:
* * *
Matt,
For starters it took 97 days for it to be completed, and there are still things I have to live with like an odd nub on the peak of the porch and cut shingles. The salesman did not measure my existing gutters or the size of board needed to connect the house and porch, but there's more. Let's take a look at the timeline:
8/11 Roof replaced. I picked up 3 pails of garbage since, total. Shingles overhung the gutters on the porch up to 2.5 inches, and the aforementioned nub. The board connecting the porch to the house did not cover the old caulk that was there. The board was cut but not painted, and right where a piece of flashing would have held water. The other side reused the old flashing, bent up and not cleaned up at all.
8/13 & 14 Gutter crew arrived late afternoon. My house gutters are six inch, but they arrived with 5 inch for the porch. They asked me, and I sighed and figured 5 inch was adequate for the porch and let them proceed, but certainly not ideal. When the porch gutters and gutter covers were completed they let me know they would be back the next day to put the gutter covers on the house since they only had 5 inch.
8/18 I texted Isaac, ignored.
8/20 I texted salesman Tony about Isaac not responding. I finally spoke with Isaac later that day and we set up a meeting for the next Tuesday, 8/25, at 3:30 pm. In the meantime I collected the third pail of garbage.
8/25 Arrived home from work expecting to meet Isaac, who apparently had shown up early to do some shoddy 'repairs' and was conveniently gone long before I got home, ignoring the fact we had a set time. My wife happened to be home so he went to the door and tried to get her to sign off as complete. Unacceptable.
8/26 I texted Julia asking for Isaac's supervisor's name and number since Isaac apparently did not want to meet with me. Also, at 4:00 pm that day the leftover supplies got picked up - 15 days after the roof was replaced.
8/27 I was put into contact with you, Matt. We spoke that afternoon and went over my issues, and made an appointment for 9/1. You saw the issues, Matt, and at the time appeared to agree with me. At this time I was still affable as things do happen and I understand that.
9/20 @12:00 I had bread about to come out of the oven and the Packers were lining up for the kickoff when I had two people come to my door and want me to show them the overhanging shingles. I said no, I was busy and to go to the porch. I should have told them to come back another time, but I wanted the job fixed. My second concession to go along with the gutters.
9/22 I emailed you Matt, and it was ignored.
9/24 I received a text from someone at the roofing company saying that Isaac told them it was ready for a final walkthrough and asked to set up a time. I replied that Isaac was mistaken. I was dealing with Matt now and am still not satisfied. I also noted that the communication with and apparently within your company was lacking. The next day I received an apology text, and that you were out of office until the next Tuesday but they would check with you.
9/30 50 days after the roof was replaced Tony the salesman submitted my supplemental claim to the insurance company. Still no word from you, Matt. I had not had contact with you since 9/1.
10/7 I sent a follow up email to you, Matt. Ignored again.
10/12 & 13 I finally texted you to verify if you even received my emails. A day later I still had no response so I texted you again to state that going forward I do not want anyone showing up at the house to do anything without my prior knowledge and approval. Six minutes later I received a text from you, apologizing and acknowledging that you did receive my emails and he would try his best to communicate better with me as they finish up my project and that I should look for an email shortly. This is our first contact since 9/1, 42 days.
10/14 I received a text from you that you had not forgotten about me, you've just been so busy, but you would still get an email out to me with an update.
10/31 17 days later I received an email from you stating that you submitted a service request for Jake to complete the remaining items and that Jake would reach out to me "directly."
11/4 You texted me to say that Jake "will be call you to schedule this completion service." That's twice you said Jake himself would reach out.
11/5 I received a text from Julia, not Jake, to schedule a time for Jake to come out. I then replied to your 10/31 email to state the things I would have discussed with Jake, had I spoken to him.
11/6 Julia texted again and we settled on the next Tuesday, 11/10, for Jake to meet me at 3:30.
11/9 Over the weekend I received payment for my supplemental insurance claim, Which was less than half of what Tony indicated I could get before I signed with your company.
11/10 I met Jake, and work was completed on 11/16.
Is this really acceptable to you? I was promised an A+ BBB, Roofing Company of the Year, premium workmanship job. And I bypassed lesser quotes to get that kind of service. Did I get that kind of service, Matt?
I have to live with this experience, a nub on my porch, cut shingles, shingles on the garage that are flush on one side and overhanging 1/2 to 3/4 inches on the other, . And I have not walked on the house roof myself to look for other issues. Should I hire someone to do that, Matt? I want $4,000 knocked off the final bill.
Regards,
* * *
What do you think I'll get as a response? If it's not anything I can work with I'm going to request a meeting with the owner.














